Irony Of Fences To Keep People In Or Out

Not since the parsing of "what the meaning of isby government to someone who has committed
is" by President Clinton has Congress had such aa political offense or broken a law."
challenge. Now the solons are nit-picking "amnesty"Thus, amnesty is a virtual land mine strewn on
- what to do with 12 million illegal immigrants doingour borders. Instant citizenship, for example, await
menial labor that Americans will not.Cubans if they can "set foot" on American soil.
President Bush proposes to regulate the inflow ofHaitians and other third-world people who sneak in
aliens and their drain on government socialand caught are deported forthwith.
services. This while accommodating neededUpon a surge of illegal immigrants in 1986,
manual labor with a "guest worker" program andPresident Reagan signed the Simpson-Rodino Bill
ultimate citizenship.granting amnesty to 2 million Mexicans who could
California, New Mexico Arizona and Texas areprove continuous residence in the U.S. since 1982.
confused - nothing new - about what to do withIncluded in the program were penalties for
Mexicans sneaking across the border. For theemployers who hired illegals. Nonetheless, the
most part, illegals are hard working and lawsurge of illegals increased with counterfeit birth
abiding. Though they give full value in labor, theycertificates and Social Security cards. The flow of
cling to the culture that drove them to flee andundocumented aliens continued.
can not function without coddling language.Today's House bill would build 700 miles of
Until this year, illegals kept a low profile. Then, bytriple-wire fence along the 2,000-mile border with
prodding from the U.S. Communist Party, theyMexico. A Senate bill would cut the fence to 350
reached critical mass with street demonstrations.miles plus 190 miles of "vehicle barrier." The cost
Such protests promoting "immigrant rights" (awould be approximately $3.8 million per mile over
stunning oxymoron) are self-defeating for thosethree-years.
who steal into a country and claim squatter rights.Critics contend a partial fence is useless. However,
Traffic signs, ballots and public documents mustas San Diego discovered, it would funnel
be printed in Spanish to accommodate Hispanicsimmigrants to places where they could be better
who will not, or cannot, assimilate.controlled.
Florida and California could become a foreignIn the meantime, Congress and Bush would
language enclave like Quebec, Canada - equal butattempt to stop illegals, drug smugglers and
dysfunctional, separated by language.terrorists with 6,000 National Guardsmen while the
We have 12 million Muslims in the U.S. and likeBig Fence is built.
numbers of Chinese, Asian Indians andAmericans shudder at the concept of fences and
descendants of Europeans of many languages. Ifmilitarized borders. Yet, both are facts of life in a
we lose the "melting pot," we become stateless.global community laced with religious terrorists.
Local, state and national governments sayHistorically there was the Great Wall of China,
unrestricted infiltration of impoverished, unskilledHadrian's Wall of England and the West Bank
and under-educated people is a financial burden onFence of Israel. All were built at great expense
American citizen-taxpayers.and did little to stop terrorism. The Soviet Union's
President Bush proposes a temporary "guestIron Curtain and Berlin Wall after World War II
worker" program and "a path to citizenship" fordivided Europe. A "demilitarized fence" still divides
productive illegals after they pay a fine of someNorth and South Korea.
sort and prove long-term employment. He alsoYet, there is a profound difference between the
would require sophisticated "biometric" identificationfences by sub-human nations to keep their
cards - with expiration dates- to thwart fakeoppressed people in - and that of the proposed
citizenship.American fence to keep self-centered people,
A majority of House members call this "amnesty"criminals and terrorists out.
and unfair to the thousands of skilled emigrants ofLet us celebrate the difference.
other countries waiting for lawful entrance andMay 21, 2006
citizenship. These latter, incidentally, are required.
to speak English -the language of global economyClick here to see this article on Lindsey Williams's
and the glue that binds disparate cultures.website
Webster defines amnesty as: "a pardon granted.